Debunking Common Roofing Misconceptions to Protect Your Home and Save Money

May 8, 2024

15 Roofing Myths Every DFW Homeowner Should Stop Believing

Mythbusters Myths Vs Facts Phillips Home Improvements Image


As a homeowner in the Dallas-Fort Worth area, you’ve likely heard your fair share of advice about your roof. From well-meaning neighbors to family members, everyone seems to have an opinion on what’s best for your home’s crowning glory. But how much of this advice is actually true?

At Phillips Home Improvements, we’ve seen our fair share of roofing myths circulating among DFW homeowners. These misconceptions can lead to costly mistakes and even put your home at risk. So, let’s debunk some of the most common roofing myths once and for all!

Myth 1: All Roofing Asphalt Shingles Are the Same

Not all asphalt shingles are created equal. In fact, there’s a wide range of quality when it comes to shingle roofs. Higher-end architectural shingles offer better durability, longer lifespans, and more aesthetic appeal compared to basic 3-tab shingles.

When it’s time for a roof replacement, don’t just settle for the cheapest option. Invest in quality shingles from a reputable manufacturer. Your roof will thank you!

Myth 2: You Can Simply Layer New Roofing Shingles Over Old Ones

While laying new shingles over an existing roof might seem like a cost-effective solution, it’s actually a short-term fix that can lead to long-term problems. The added weight of the new layer can strain your roof’s structure, leading to sagging and even collapse. Plus, any existing issues with your old shingles will remain unaddressed.

For a roof that stands the test of time, always opt for a complete tear-off and replacement.

Myth 3: A Roof Inspection Is Only Necessary When You Notice Damage

Many homeowners believe that roof inspections are only necessary when there are visible signs of damage, such as leaks or missing shingles. This misconception could not be further from the truth. Regular roof inspections are crucial in identifying potential issues long before they become visible or cause significant damage. An experienced professional can spot early signs of wear and tear, ensuring that minor repairs are made in a timely manner to extend the life of your roof. Don’t wait for a problem to manifest visibly; proactive inspections can save you time, money, and stress in the long run.

Myth 4: It’s Safe to Pressure Wash Your Roof

A common misconception is that pressure washing your roof is a safe and effective way to remove dirt and algae. However, this practice can be more harmful than beneficial. High-pressure water can strip away granules from asphalt shingles, leading to premature aging and weakening of your roof. Additionally, aggressive washing can introduce water into areas where it doesn’t belong, potentially causing leaks and water damage. Instead of pressure washing, opt for gentler methods of cleaning recommended by roofing professionals to keep your roof in optimal condition without causing harm. Remember, preserving your roof’s integrity is vital to maintaining your home’s overall health and safety.

Myth 5: You Can Handle Roof Repairs Yourself

DIY culture is alive and well, but when it comes to your roof, it’s best to leave repairs to the professionals. Roofing work is not only complex but also dangerous. One misstep could lead to serious injury or even worse.

Plus, improper repairs can end up causing more harm than good. A professional roofing contractor has the expertise and equipment to get the job done right the first time.

Myth 6: Flashing Only Needs to Be Replaced When You Get a New Roof

Flashing, the material that protects the most vulnerable areas of your roof, is often overlooked until a new roof is needed. However, waiting that long can lead to unnecessary damage. Flashing should be inspected regularly and replaced if it shows signs of wear or damage. Staying proactive about flashing maintenance can prevent water damage and extend the life of your current roof significantly.

Myth 7: More Attic Insulation Always Means Better Energy Efficiency

It’s a common misconception that loading up on insulation will invariably improve a home’s energy efficiency. While proper attic insulation is key to maintaining temperature control, there is such a thing as too much insulation. Over-insulating can actually trap moisture and reduce ventilation in the attic, leading to potential roof rot and mold issues, undermining the roof’s integrity and indoor air quality.

Myth 8: It’s Okay to Skip the Underlayment to Save Costs

Underlayment, the water-resistant barrier installed beneath your shingles, is a critical component of your roofing system. Skipping the underlayment as a cost-saving measure is a risky move that can lead to extensive damage. The underlayment provides an additional layer of protection against water infiltration, especially in areas prone to high winds and driving rain. Omitting this critical component can compromise the roof’s integrity, leading to leaks, mold, and structural damage. It’s a vital part of a roofing system that ensures your investment and home are protected from the elements.

Myth 9: Dark-Colored Shingles Will Significantly Increase Cooling Costs

It’s a common misconception that dark-colored shingles result in higher cooling costs compared to lighter ones. While it’s true that dark colors absorb more heat, the impact on your home’s temperature is minimal. Modern roofing materials are designed to reflect heat, mitigating the effect of shingle color on your home’s energy efficiency. Adequate attic insulation and ventilation play a far more significant role in controlling your home’s temperature.

Myth 10: The Color of Your Shingles Doesn’t Affect Your Home’s Resale Value

Contrary to popular belief, the color of your shingles can impact your home’s appeal to potential buyers. Aesthetic considerations play a significant role in home values, and roofing color that complements your home’s overall design can enhance curb appeal. Choosing a shingle color that aligns with your community’s norms and the natural surroundings can appeal to buyers and potentially increase your home’s market value.

Myth 11: Shingles Are All About Aesthetics and Don’t Contribute to Roof Performance

While shingles certainly add to the visual appeal of your home, their role is not merely cosmetic. High-quality shingles provide a critical barrier against water, wind, and sun damage, contributing significantly to the overall performance and longevity of your roof. Investing in durable, high-performance shingles can save homeowners money in the long run by reducing the need for repairs and extending the life of the roof.

Myth 12: Ventilation is Only Necessary in Summer

Many homeowners mistakenly believe that roof ventilation is only important during the summer months to allow hot air to escape. However, ventilation plays a crucial role year-round. Proper ventilation helps to regulate the temperature and moisture levels in the attic, preventing issues like ice dams in the winter and extending the life of your roof by reducing the risk of damp-related damage.

Myth 13: A Few Missing Shingles Don’t Pose a Problem

Missing shingles can compromise your roof’s integrity and lead to water intrusion and damage over time. Even a single shingle’s absence can expose your roof to moisture and the elements. It’s crucial to replace missing or damaged shingles immediately to maintain your roof’s protective barrier.

Myth 14: Gutters Have Little to do With Roof Health

The role of gutters is frequently underestimated, with some homeowners viewing them as merely auxiliary to the roof. Gutters play a vital role in directing water away from the roof and foundation of your home, preventing water damage, erosion, and foundation issues. Clogged or inefficient gutters can lead to water backup and seepage that might cause significant roof and structural damage over time.

Myth 15: All Roof Warranties Provide Comprehensive Coverage

Homeowners may assume that all roof warranties offer a blanket protection against any eventualities. However, warranties vary significantly between manufacturers and may only cover specific aspects such as materials or workmanship. Some might not cover damage due to certain weather events or improper installation. It is important to thoroughly understand the terms and limits of your roof’s warranty to ensure you are adequately protected and know what to expect in terms of coverage and claims.

The Bottom Line

Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements. Don’t let common myths and misconceptions put your roof – and your home – at risk.

At Phillips Home Improvements, we’re here to help you separate fact from fiction. Our team of experienced roofing professionals is dedicated to providing top-notch roofing services, from repairs to full replacements.

Ready to give your roof the care it deserves? Contact us today for a free consultation! Your home’s crown jewel will thank you.